Samuel, its a very valid question, but because I live and work in Brampton, and am near Toronto, black clients and south asian clients are really common. I do watch carefully to see who is rejected, but I have not noticed a pattern broken down by race, moreso by offences. I will let ZMichelle answer about 'Review Panel Assessment" so i am not hogging all the answers.
I don't think it will play a part in the adjudication of your waiver, but its way too much of a fluke that black men were all being pulled in at Clagary airport on the same day.
1. Could have been an alert was out for a black male between the ages of so and so and so and so that day
2. Racism can be very unconscious. This is the big debate about racism isn't it. People think you can only be racist consciously. Officers are pulling in 'suspicious males' but when the numbers are tallied, realized that 'suspicious' equated more times to 'not white' than white, thats unconscious racism. They don't even realize they are doing it.
HatsBootsHats
“You and I know that nobody knows what the agent that works at Homeland Security or USCIS is thinking when he looks at waivers. Five year waivers right off the bat are not common. We saw a trend last year because of backlogs but right now 1 year waivers seem to be the norm once more.”
This statement is WRONG. 5 year waivers right off the bat ARE common right now. They stopped for about a month, which coincided with John Kelly taking over Homeland Security for a short time. I posted about that here in this forum actually. Then back to 5 years. The backlog was created by the bombings in France by the way. It had no bearing on the length of time waivers were being given for. Could you give some proof of your claims? Ken and Michelle can both chime in about what they are seeing in terms of length of times for first time waiver applicants.
My company does Pardons and Waivers. I have a set price list. Most people pay by credit card or debit. Some even try and write the expense off, or get their company to pay for it. There isn't a lot of wiggle room to evade taxes. Weird allegation. Since I pointed out where you were wrong and I have a public Facebook profile I assume you will next point out I don't have attractive children or something. Challenge my age?