@Michele
So you can look at the waiver application 2 ways.
1. You can do the bare minimum.
2. You can do the application exactly how it is supposed to be done.
For #1, whatever happens, happens. If someone at Homeland Security goes "you know what, I'm going to teach you a lesson, and just give you a one year waiver"...well, you did a lazy waiver, you got a result you deserved. I have seen waivers where they dropped people down because of this exact thing.
For #2, you did everything you could to get the longest waiver possible.
But this is life in a nutshell, isn't it? "How you do anything, is how you do EVERYTHING". Its every 5 years. I am paid to do a GOOD job, not a LAZY job.
When I coach sports, rugby and basketball, I tell the kids the same thing. Winners do everything they can to succeed. Losers make excuses.
This forum gives you ALL the answers. Its free. If you still decide "nah, I'm just going to do the bare minimum"....then who am I to tell you differently?
I will tell you that SOMEONE will do a lazy waiver, get a 1 year, blame everyone but themselves, and then when they re-apply, the fee will go up. And then they will bitch "its a money grab", conveniently ignoring that Homeland Security actually doesn't care if you ever travel there again.